Cultivating trust in technology-mediated sustainable agricultural research

Authors: RATURI, ANKITA - Purdue University; ACKROYD, VICTORIA - University Of Maryland; CHASE, CARLENE - University Of Florida; DAVIS, BRIAN - University Of Maryland; MYERS, ROB - University Of Missouri; PONCET, AURELIE - North Carolina State University; RAMOS-GIRALDO, PAULA - North Carolina State University; REJESUS, RODERICK - North Carolina State University; ROBERTSON, ALISON - Iowa State University; RUARK, MATTHEW - University Of Wisconsin; SEEHAVER-EAGEN, SARAH - North Carolina State University; THOMPSON, JENNIFER - University Of Georgia; Mirsky, Steven

Submitted to: Agronomy Journal
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: 11/30/2021
Publication Date: 12/17/2021
Citation: Raturi, A., Ackroyd, V., Chase, C., Davis, B., Myers, R., Poncet, A., Ramos-Giraldo, P., Rejesus, R., Robertson, A., Ruark, M., Seehaver-Eagen, S., Thompson, J.J., Mirsky, S.B. 2021. Cultivating trust in technology-mediated sustainable agricultural research. Agronomy Journal. https://doi.org/10.1002/agj2.20974.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/agj2.20974

Interpretive Summary: We formed the Precision Sustainable Agriculture (PSA) team to conduct interdisciplinary research and technology development to improve adoption and practice of knowledge-intensive sustainable agricultural practices such as cover cropping. In this paper, we share our approach to cultivating trust among diverse stakeholders (researchers, farmers, extensionists, agricultural and information specialists, private and public entities) vested in agricultural data collection, management, and use. Our trust framework describes how we aim to be trusted with data (through preserving privacy and increasing stakeholder agency) and trusted in the process (through practicing transparency and accountability). It is operationalized through a series of social and technical infrastructures. Our project governance, stakeholder engagement tools and activities, and technology development methods aim to promote transparency and accountability in our process. We use a maturity model to govern data acquisition to ensure the only robust, privacy-preserving technologies are deployed on our partner farms, and describe evolving mechanisms for handling data with varying sensitivity. Finally, we share preliminary work on managing and anticipating data use, and the challenges on the horizon for cultivating trust in agricultural technologies and data-driven agriculture. This information will be useful to scientists working with data from agricultural stakeholders.

Technical Abstract: We formed the Precision Sustainable Agriculture (PSA) team to conduct interdisciplinary research and technology development to improve adoption and practice of knowledge-intensive sustainable agricultural practices such as cover cropping. In this paper, we share our approach to cultivating trust among diverse stakeholders (researchers, farmers, extensionists, agricultural and information specialists, private and public entities) vested in agricultural data collection, management, and use. Our trust framework describes how we aim to be trusted with data (through preserving privacy and increasing stakeholder agency) and trusted in the process (through practicing transparency and accountability). It is operationalized through a series of social and technical infrastructures. Our project governance, stakeholder engagement tools and activities, and technology development methods aim to promote transparency and accountability in our process. We use a maturity model to govern data acquisition to ensure the only robust, privacy-preserving technologies are deployed on our partner farms, and describe evolving mechanisms for handling data with varying sensitivity. Finally, we share preliminary work on managing and anticipating data use, and the challenges on the horizon for cultivating trust in agricultural technologies and data-driven agriculture.