Thresholds and alternative states in neotropical dry forest in response to fire severity

Authors: PEINETTI, RAÚL - University Of La Pampa; Bestelmeyer, Brandon; CHIRINO, CLAUDIA - University Of La Pampa; FLORENCIA, VIVALDA - University Of La Pampa; KIN, ALICIA - University Of La Pampa

Submitted to: Ecological Applications
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: 10/29/2023
Publication Date: 12/10/2023
Citation: Peinetti, R.H., Bestelmeyer, B.T., Chirino, C.C., Florencia, V.L., Kin, A.G. 2023. Thresholds and alternative states in neotropical dry forest in response to fire severity. Ecological Applications. 34(2). Article e2937. https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.2937.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.2937

Interpretive Summary: We evaluated the response of a dry forest ecosystem to increasing fire severity to estimate a threshold at which forest resilience is lost. Threshold identification can help minimize undesirable forest transitions to shrub thicket states that have reduced utility for livestock production and other services.  Our results provide insights on fire-vegetation relationships that can guide the management of a critical South American forest ecosystem.

Technical Abstract: Neotropical xerophytic forest ecosystems evolved with fires that shaped their resilience to disturbance events. However, it is unknown whether forest resilience to fires persists under a new fire regime influenced by anthropogenic disturbance and climate change. We asked whether there was evidence for a fire severity threshold causing an abrupt transition from a forest to an alternative shrub thicket state in the presence of typical postfire management. We studied a heterogeneous wildfire event to assess medium-term effects (11'years) of varying fire severity in a xerophytic Caldén forest in central Argentina. We conducted vegetation surveys in patches that were exposed to low (LFS), medium (MFS), and high (HFS) fire severities but had similar prefire woody canopy cover. Satellite images were used to quantify fire severity using a delta Normalized Burning Ratio (dNBR) and to map prefire canopy cover. Postfire total woody canopy cover was higher in low and medium than high severity patches, but the understory woody component was highest in HFS patches. The density of woody plants was over three times higher under HFS than MFS and LFS due to the contribution of small woody plants to the total density. Unlike LFS and MFS patches, the small plants in HFS patches were persistent, multistem shrubs that resulted from the resprouting of top-killed Prosopis caldenia trees and, more importantly, from young shrubs that probably established after the wildfire. Our results suggest that the Caldén forest is resilient to fires of low to moderate severities but not to high-severity fires. Fire severities with dNBR values > ~600 triggered an abrupt transition to a shrub thicket state. Postfire grazing and controlled-fire treatments likely contributed to shrub dominance after high-severity wildfire. Forest to shrub thicket transitions enable recurring high-severity fire events. We propose that repeated fires combined with grazing can trap the system in a shrub thicket state. Further studies are needed to determine whether the relationships between fire and vegetation structure examined in this case study represent general mechanisms of irreversible state changes across the Caldenal forest region and whether analogous threshold relationships exist in other fire-prone woodland ecosystems.